inafoxhole (inafoxhole) wrote,

The Age of American Unreason

I started listening to the audiobook for this on Saturday, and was awake most of Saturday/Sunday night listening to it. While it's true that my sleep schedule has become increasingly bizarre, it really was also that good. I found myself listening to the naration, thinking frequently that I know dozens of otherwise intelligent people who really need to read this book. This was particularly true during her discussion of junk science. I find this to be one of the most frustrating aspects of trying to have intelligent coversations with my fellow Mensans, even atheists. The ideology, particularly the anti-expert sentiments and global warming denying, and so on, are particularly bad. The sexism is sometimes also irritating, but it doesn't come up nearly as often as the anti-science sentiments.

But also bothersome are the anti-intellectual sentiments of those who pretend to be intellectuals. Frankly, yes, I consider myself to be an intellectual (certianly with plenty more to learn, of course). I have an absurdly broad education, both self-taught and from actual degrees, and I get a little ticked at people who suggest that I can't talk intelligently about something closely related to one of my fields of study, or that I can't read a book and reliably report and discuss information gleaned from a non-fiction book related to the topic under discussion. And the objections almost always come in the form of claims based on ideology (that I apparently just contradicted), or because of wrong "facts" that they have no evidence for, but just happen to believe because it supports their ideology, or because they've heard it so often on Fox News that it must be true.

Unfortunately, I doubt that the people who really need to read this book the most would take any of it to heart even if they did.
Tags: age of american unreason, audiobooks, mensa, susan jacoby

  • hard lesson

    This article should be a hard lesson for the public on the way science is done, and why it is done the way it is. I often hear complaints about how…

  • Life Line Screening

    It's just not a good day for the religion stuff. I got a flyer in the mail for "Life Line Screening" to be held at the Holy Spirit Catholic Church…

  • Shall we talk about a biased study?

    Religion and health care should mix. And what about the patients who are not religious? Do you think it's a help to them if you force religion down…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded